Hand Wringing and Pearl Clutching Redux

In my original post on this subject (September 25th, 2025) I referred to Europe. In it I wondered aloud if Europe might begin to bare its teeth. They seem to have done so of late with country after country giving the US the cold shoulder in various ways. Mostly, they have openly said that they are moving away from buying American weapons and technology. No easy task, but trade policies that many in the EU are determined to implement (and many like Norway, Holland, and Denmark already have).

This post is not about Schadenfreude. I am not writing about being gleeful that many hard-working Americans are suffering because Europeans have decided to distance themselves from buying American-made products. There was no need to do so until the US president and his lapdog VP decided to openly become insulting bullies. As they say in the US, FAFO. Well, the midterm results are opening eyes across the political spectrum. Some Americans saw their leaders FA and now they are finding out what it means.

Enough about Europe. Our current PM actually led the charge to move away from the US (and continues to do so). Let me be clear: it would be both stupid and extremely difficult to reduce our trade with the US too far. Yes, fences have been broken, but I believe they can be mended — and made stronger. To quote a favourite American poet (Robert Frost, Mending Wall, 1914) “strong fences make good neighbors.” Meanwhile, our PM abandoned much of the virtue signalling implemented by his predecessor and expanded trade with both China and India (3 Billion of the world’s 8 billion people). Let us not have any illusions that either of these two countries is benign or worthy of a warm and jovial embrace; they are not. But that is not what Mr. Carney is doing. He is merely opening lines of communication and trade that will be beneficial to both sides, just as he has been doing with all other countries and still trying to do with an increasingly isolationist America.

Canada, along with Europe still believes strongly in a rules-based order and feels that international diplomacy must take precedence over violence (or the threat of violence). We also believe in free trade and, to the extent that it is possible, open markets for the movement of goods and services. Certainly, China and India have behaved badly in the past, but both now seem more open to dealing with us more equitably. To quote another American (Ronald Reagan) we must trust but verify.

In my original post on this matter I referenced Robert Fulghum’s All I Really Need to Know I Learned in Kindergarten, a short book filled with timeless home truths and one that has endured with a lesson taught by every parent to a child when they encounter a bully at school. Do not be cowed by a bully. Mr. Carney’s pivot away from a bullying America, although temporarily damaging to some parts of our economy, has begun to pay off for other parts of the Canadian economy.

It has been a slow pivot and there are some still complaining loudly that it won’t work (Pierre Poilievre), but there are clear signs that it is working. PM Carney is set to embark on a worldwide summit tour to build more bridges with Europe and Asia. Ireland, the Philippines, Cambodia, and China are all on the PM’s travel/trade agenda as part of his plan to diversify our economy by building newer and stronger relations with countries all over the world. The early signs? Our exports to China are hitting record levels. Our aluminum exports to Europe are also hitting record levels. It’s been about a year since we reset our trade parameters with China and the two way trade between us hit a record $37 Billion in the third quarter alone driven mostly by energy exports out of Alberta where crude oil exports jumped an average of over 150% (the province that complains loudly that the Feds do nothing for them).

Moral of the story? Walk away from bullies and be patient. Good things come to those who are patient.

5 thoughts on “Hand Wringing and Pearl Clutching Redux”

  1. Point of order. I live in Alberta, and I don’t hear Albertans complain that the Federal Government does nothing for them (at least not at rates beyond what you hear in other provinces). If anything, the complaints are the opposite

    Like

    1. Tom, perhaps you don’t listen to your premier. You know, the one who spent hundred of millions of provincial dollars to pay for a referendum that included consideration of separation.

      Like

  2. I’m completely sympathetic with and fully understand Canada looking to broaden its trade partnerships, because the US has proven itself a volatile and unfaithful partner, and while I hope that changes in the future, other countries can’t wait. They need to chart their own paths now and if the US decides to be something other than a clown show led by liars, freaks, and grifters in a few years, great. Awesome news for everyone.

    My one caveat: “China [has] behaved badly in the past, but…now [seems] more open to dealing with us more equitably.”

    You’re kidding yourself if you think the PRC is doing this. You may want to trade with them—I mean, everyone does, it’s functionally impossible to stay detached from such a large and global integrated market—but do not think for a moment that they will not steal, spy, exploit, and twist and bend every rule you care about in the rules-based order. You say “do not be cowed by a bully.” 100 percent agree—and the PRC is a bully to its own neighbors, and its bullying has had a far more martial—and literally deadly—aspect than the bullying the US has shamefully undertaken the last few years. You say walk away from bullies—but you walk closer to the PRC, you’re walking closer a bully cut from the same cloth as Putin’s Russia. They just haven’t killed as many people; but they have killed people, just ask the Filipinos or the Uyghurs.

    Many countries who hewed closer the PRC injudiciously, especially through One Belt One Road, have come to regret it. There is no need for Canada to put itself in a similar position.

    Like

  3. Ian, I do not disagree and you are correct to point out that China cannot be fully trusted. What I am saying is NOT that we embrace China. We have not done that. We are trading with them (annd the Philipines, and Viet Nam and Europe and and and). For most of my life we were lazy about trade and commerce. We need to get smarter and now have a PM who is pushing our industries to be better.

    That is what I am saying.

    PS: Forgot to wish The Corps a happy birthday.

    Like

Leave a Reply